Let’s start with our ‘review of reviews’, choosing one of those less enthusiast one, which has been published by the famous Web site InfoSync. In this concise but complete enough test the EEE PC scored a 56%, which as you know means ’sufficient’ or ‘good enough’ to us all. But what were the pros and the cons in InfoSync review of the Asus EEE PC? Mainly, the most criticized components of Asus’ subnotebook were the keyboard, the trackpad and the display, for their small size, of course. Heck, you’re talking about a SUBnotebook, guys! Did you notice the first three letters? S-U-B means ‘under’, so such a device should me meant to be S-M-A-L-L, don’t you think? I’ve already have more than a chance to talk about Dialogue FlyBook’s keyboard, and its clumsy mini-joypad input system used instead of a trackpad, and I was talking about a very, very expensive product, there. If you need a large keyboard, then buy a full fledged one, together with a mouse, and plug them in the EEE PC’s USB ports, damn it! You have a choice of foldable, rollable and maybe even inflatable keyboard, out there, and about mice there’s even more choice, not mentioning the wireless options. So, what’s the point? Oh, yes, the display! Like others, out there, you’ve mentioned the two uselessly large speakers on both sides of the screen as a cause of the latter’s smaller size. Why don’t you just see the REAL thing? Asus decided to put a 7 inch display on this machine, for a start, to lower production costs, but they also looked far beyond and saw the opportunity for less cheap models, so a larger frame was the natural consequence, and putting something like a couple of speakers in the remaining estate was more than justified and wise as a choice. Also, having a black frame around a display, especially an LCD one, visibly enhances its brightness factor, don’t you think? As Apple’s engineers who designed the latest iMac breed, for example.
Also, InfoSync reviewer(s?) describe the EEE PC ‘not suitabe for them‘ and as ‘probably a better choice for young students and hackers than for business travelers looking for something between a smartphone and a 15-inch laptop‘. Er, is there anybody else between YOU, young students, hackers and business travelers? Let me think… oh yes, everybody else, and they’re a damn lot of people! OK, maybe they don’t usually wander around InfoSync offices, but probably you, hackers and businessmen are just enough to fill those corridors and cubicles. And, just about, the something between a smartphone and a 15-inch laptop part of the sentence: try writing your articles or browse your site’s pages on a smartphone, then try carrying your powerful and ‘comfortable’ 15 inch laptops under your arm like a book, then let’s have a coffee and talk about your satisfying experiences of mobile computing, uh?
OK, I know, I just seem a little bit (just a little, yes?) on the Asus side, but let me remind you that the one writing, here on this site, has been testing and reviewing PDAs, smartphones, Tablet PCs, laptops and many other mobile devices since the Apple Newton era. And let me also remind them the meaning of reviewing a product: as journalist, we try to focus on our readers, not on ourselves, and to address their needs and not ours.
If (as you wrote in the final verdict near the unfair score table) the best thing about the EEE PC is its price, why don’t you just ask yourself how did Asus manage to keep the cost low? Ever heard about ‘compromise’? If you put your nose outside your hitech-filled-offices and ask people, you’ll be surprised about their willingness to give up some hardware stuff in a product they’re going to purchase if that helps avoiding a ransack of their back account. If you really want to evaluate Asus’ EEE PC subnotebook, try comparing its hardware and software with that of another product in the same tag price, or make some true and detailed comparisons with smaller and larger devices, for example.
So, let me end this ‘review of a review’ giving a 56% back to InfoSync editor(s?), as their test was an ‘almost good enough’ one, after all. Try it again, InfoSync.